Grabbing the Stack for Fun & Profit

So I'm at a work, trying to track down some memory leaks in a long-running VC++ application (actually a COM object DLL out the back of a .NET web service - you don't need to know that bit). No problem, I'll use the Microsoft C Run-Time library memory debugging features.. a quick read / web search later, I have the necessary incantation in a common code header:

 #include <stdlib.h>
 #include <crtdbg.h>
 #define new new(_NORMAL_BLOCK,__FILE__,__LINE__)

..all goes well, the application terminates and I get a dump file of leaked memory blocks: 34MB of text, with very few file and line numbers. Of those entries that do provide file and line numbers, they're all just a few places, buffer management classes that could be called from anywhere. Back to square one.

OK, so I need more context, in particular I need to see the stack when those allocations are made. No problem, I can use a debug memory allocation hook function, take a stack back trace for each alloc, remove it for each free then dump what's left at the end.

Attempt 1: StackWalker

So - how to grab a stack back trace? I first came across some excellent but rather involved code from Jochen Kalmbach: which he wrote primarily for printing a crash dump stack trace with lots of extra info.

This turns out to be pretty easy to use, but rather slow, mostly because it does symbol lookups while walking the stack. I'm seeing ~20 million allocations during a test run, and StackWalker is tracing at about 100/sec, so a test run would take 200k secs or about 2.3 days. Try again.

Attempt 2: CaptureStackBackTrace

My Google fu improved after attempt 1, and I found CaptureStackBackTrace, a kernel/RTL function that does exactly what it says on the tin - fabulous and fast, no symbol lookups or callbacks to read process memory, using this made no discernible difference to memory allocation speed - winner!

CRT Oops

So now I can run a test - result: ~20 million allocations, followed by zero frees. Nothing. Not one. That can't be right can it?

Back to the debugger to trace what's going on in the memory allocation hook function where I'm supposed to be matching allocation requests with free's and removing those from the list to print out. Turns out that when Microsoft wrote the debug memory library they chose to not provide the hook function with any useful information when callers free memory blocks, so I'm unable to associate free's with allocs. Genius. A little more digging and some bodgery results in me being able to extract the allocation request ID and record memory leakage with stack traces like this:

#include <stdlib.h>
#include <crtdbg.h>
#include <DbgHelp.h>

// stolen from dbgint.h - because M$ in their wisdom don't provide matching request serial numbers between alloc/free hook calls. Sheesh.
#define nNoMansLandSize 4
typedef struct _CrtMemBlockHeader
        struct _CrtMemBlockHeader * pBlockHeaderNext;
        struct _CrtMemBlockHeader * pBlockHeaderPrev;
        char *                      szFileName;
        int                         nLine;
#ifdef _WIN64
        /* These items are reversed on Win64 to eliminate gaps in the struct
         * and ensure that sizeof(struct)%16 == 0, so 16-byte alignment is
         * maintained in the debug heap.
        int                         nBlockUse;
        size_t                      nDataSize;
#else  /* _WIN64 */
        size_t                      nDataSize;
        int                         nBlockUse;
#endif  /* _WIN64 */
        long                        lRequest;
        unsigned char               gap[nNoMansLandSize];
        /* followed by:
         *  unsigned char           data[nDataSize];
         *  unsigned char           anotherGap[nNoMansLandSize];
} _CrtMemBlockHeader;
#define pbData(pblock) ((unsigned char *)((_CrtMemBlockHeader *)pblock + 1))
#define pHdr(pbData) (((_CrtMemBlockHeader *)pbData)-1)

// require dbghelp.lib for SymXX() calls
#pragma comment(lib, "dbghelp.lib")


// collect stack traces during allocation, remove when free'd
static int maxreq=20000000;
static ULONG skipframes=5;
static ULONG maxframes=10;
typedef struct {
        PVOID trc[10];
        ULONG len;
        ULONG cnt;
} stack_t;
static stack_t stacks[20000000];

static volatile BOOL inWalk = FALSE;
static long acount = 0;
int __cdecl allochook(int type, void *usr, size_t size, int block, long req, const unsigned char *file, int line) {
        wchar_t msg[80];
        if (inWalk)     // ignore recursive requests
                return TRUE;
        inWalk = TRUE;
        if (acount%10000==0) {
                wsprintf(msg, L"%ld\n", acount);
        if (req<maxreq) {
                DWORD hash;
                switch (type) {
                case _HOOK_ALLOC:
                        // insert into map - alert collisions
                        if (0==stacks[req].len)
                        stacks[req].len=CaptureStackBackTrace(skipframes, maxframes, stacks[req].trc, &hash);
                        if (stacks[req].len>maxframes) {
                case _HOOK_REALLOC:
                        // update/insert into map - may collide
                        stacks[req].len=CaptureStackBackTrace(skipframes, maxframes, stacks[req].trc, &hash);
                        if (stacks[req].len>maxframes) {
                case _HOOK_FREE:
                        // AWOOGA! AWOOGA!! HIDEOUS BODGE ALERT!!! Recover request ID from CRT debug memory header because
                        // Microsloth DO NOT PROVIDE IT IN THE HOOK FUNCTION CALL. Numpties.
                        if (usr==NULL) {
                                OutputDebugString(L"NULL UserData in free hook\n");
                        req = pHdr(usr)->lRequest;
                        // remove from map - alert missing entries
                        if (0!=stacks[req].len) {
                        } else {
                                wsprintf(msg, L"free without alloc ID: %d\n", req);
        } else {
                OutputDebugString(L"Oops: out of request array!");
        inWalk = FALSE;
        return TRUE;
static void dumpstacks(_HFILE hFile) {
        char buf[4096];
        DWORD nw;
        int cnt=0;
        HANDLE hProc = GetCurrentProcess();
        wcstombs(buf, path, wcslen(path));
        SymInitialize(hProc, buf, TRUE);
        wsprintfA(buf, "------ stacks\r\n");
        WriteFile(hFile, buf, strlen(buf), &nw, NULL);
        for (int req=0; req<maxreq; req++) {
                if (0!=stacks[req].len) {
                        int o;
                        wsprintfA(buf, "{%d/%d}: ", req, stacks[req].cnt);
                        for (USHORT stk=0; stk<stacks[req].len && o<4080; stk++) {
                                char tmp[256];
                                char tmp2[sizeof(SYMBOL_INFO)+256] = {0};
                                SYMBOL_INFO *pSym = (SYMBOL_INFO *)tmp2;
                                pSym->MaxNameLen = 255;
                                pSym->SizeOfStruct = sizeof(SYMBOL_INFO);
                                if (SymFromAddr(hProc, (DWORD64)stacks[req].trc[stk], 0, pSym))
                                        wsprintfA(tmp, "%s (%08x),", pSym->Name, pSym->Address);
                                        wsprintfA(tmp, "%08x,", stacks[req].trc[stk]);
                                strcpy(buf+o, tmp);
                        WriteFile(hFile, buf, strlen(buf), &nw, NULL);
                        WriteFile(hFile, "\r\n", 2, &nw, NULL);
                if (req%1000==0) {
                        wsprintfA(buf, "%d/%d\n", cnt, req);


int main() {
        memset(&stacks, 0, maxreq*sizeof(stack_t));
        _CRT_ALLOC_HOOK oldHook = _CrtSetAllocHook(allochook);
        _CrtSetReportMode(_CRT_WARN, _CRTDBG_MODE_FILE);
        _CrtSetReportMode(_CRT_ERROR, _CRTDBG_MODE_FILE);
        _CrtSetReportMode(_CRT_ASSERT, _CRTDBG_MODE_FILE);
        _CrtSetReportFile(_CRT_WARN, hFile);
        _CrtSetReportFile(_CRT_ERROR, hFile);
        _CrtSetReportFile(_CRT_ASSERT, hFile);
        OutputDebugString(L"Dumping stacks\n");
        OutputDebugString(L"Dumping memory leaks\n");
        return 0;
} eh? But this at least works (whilst eating ~1GB of RAM for the tracing buffer!).

Leakage Found!

After all that entertainment, I finally had ~180k memory blocks that weren't free'd on program termination, this time with stack traces, all with a common ancestor method - victory is mine! I won't bore you with the details of the bug (besides it's proprietary code from work), but I will say that ATL COM objects are ugly voodoo, and rolling your own makes stuff much clearer (and not dependant on the paid for version of Visual Studio).

AshbySoft: StackGrabbing (last edited 2014-02-21 08:45:09 by Phlash)